Skip to main content

Internet Law Specialist Lawyers FREE CALL 0800 612 7211

Blackmailed with an intimate recording: the privacy injunction in BBG v Persons Unknown

Blackmailed with a secret recording and threats to tell my community: the privacy injunction we obtained in BBG v Persons Unknown

Case led by Reagan Brien, Solicitor specialising in internet law.

This case study is part of our privacy injunctions section.

If strangers are threatening to send an intimate recording of you to your family, your community or the press unless you pay, we can help you put an end to it, even when you have no idea who they are. Paying them, or bargaining with them, usually leads to a bigger demand, so please do neither. In 2023 we obtained an emergency privacy injunction of this kind for our client in the reported case of BBG v Persons Unknown, and in 2024 the High Court made it final.

Blackmailed with an intimate recording made without consent: what happened to our client

Our client is an openly gay man who is active in his religious community. During a private, consensual encounter in another European country, someone recorded him without his agreement. From July 2023 a group of people he could not identify used that recording to blackmail him.

They said they would release private details and explicit, intimate material to his friends and family, to his religious community and to newspapers, and so to the public at large. The fear of that publicity was the lever they used to back their demands.

He knew them only by the user names and telephone numbers they contacted him from. The numbers looked African, and the blackmailers had referred to bank transfers in Africa. There was some suggestion that organised crime lay behind it.

Why ignoring the blackmailers made the threats worse

Our client first tried to ignore them, and it did not work. The judgment records that silence appeared to lead to an escalation. On or shortly before 7 September 2023 the blackmailers made a limited disclosure on his religious community's Facebook page. It was promptly removed, but it showed they would do what they had threatened.

On 14 September he met the police. He came away understanding that arrests were unlikely to happen soon.

The experience left him more frustrated than before. Something he had wanted to keep to himself was now on record with the police, together with his name. A number of officers knew about it and it sat on police computers. Nobody suggests the police would leak information on purpose. But for someone well known, or anyone people could identify, an accidental leak, a data breach or a simple mishandling of data could be disastrous, and it would undo the very thing he went to them for.

The next day one of the blackmailers left him a missed call, which he took as a further threat, since they had no other reason to ring him.

That was the point at which waiting stopped being an option. A criminal investigation and a civil injunction can go forward side by side, and a judge can act before any arrest.

Facing something similar?Get a straight answer here

How we obtained an emergency privacy injunction against blackmailers we could not name

Our client did what most people do. He researched, looked at a number of companies and lawyers, and chose us. On the day he instructed us we did two things. First we put his mind at rest. Then we began work on his injunction. From that moment the worry was ours to carry, and we dealt with it at once.

The court record shows the pace. We issued the application on 15 September 2023, the day after he had met the police. We asked the High Court to act urgently, during the court's vacation, and Mrs Justice Hill heard us on the afternoon of Monday 18 September 2023. She said during the hearing that she would grant the injunction. She settled its final wording at a second hearing by video two days later. The claims were for misuse of private information and for harassment under section 1 of the Protection from Harassment Act 1997.

Three features of the application are worth knowing about if you are in the same position.

First, the blackmailers had no warning or notice that we intended to apply for a privacy injunction. The judge accepted that telling them in advance carried a real risk of tipping them off, so that they would publish before the court could act. It would also have shown them what our client had been doing with the police.

This is a dilemma many victims face before applying for an emergency privacy injunction: do you tell the other side what you are about to do? Sometimes notice alone is enough to make them go away. But notice given before the injunction exists can prompt them to carry out some of their threats, at a moment when no court order, no proceedings and no risk of prison stand in their way. Every case is different, and we advise each client on what we believe is in their best interest in their own circumstances.

Second, the judge made the order against "persons unknown". A court can do that where the people can be pinned down by what they have done. Here the order described them by the accounts and numbers behind the threats, which the court kept in a confidential schedule.

This is more useful than it sounds. You may not know the names or true identity of the people blackmailing you. You may think you know who they are and be wrong. An order kept broad, against persons unknown, covers whoever is in fact behind the threats, and its warning extends to anyone who knows of the order and assists a breach. Any of them could face prison for breaching the injunction.

Third, the hearing was in private and the first published order replaced our client's name with the letters BBG. The judge explained why the courts do this in blackmail cases. A court should not help a blackmailer by publicising the very thing they threaten to reveal, and victims should not be put off from coming forward.

These are the first two things we ask the court for, before anything else. One is anonymity, so that whatever happens in the end, the client stays anonymous. The other is privacy for the hearing and the papers. A private hearing means no press in the room, and we ask for the court papers to be closed to anyone outside the case. In blackmail cases the court usually agrees. Both protect the client's privacy however the application itself turns out.

The order barred the blackmailers from contacting our client or the people linked to him, and from using or passing on the private material. It required them to tell us within 48 hours about anything they had already disclosed. Unusually, it also barred them from telling anyone that the order existed until the next hearing, because of the risk that they would alert others who might publish.

She approved WhatsApp as the way to deliver the papers, since it was the only channel anyone had for reaching them, and gave permission to serve them outside the country.

"Blackmail victims should be afforded protection by the courts." Mrs Justice Hill, BBG v Persons Unknown.
Facing something similar?Get a straight answer here

How the case ended: default judgment, a permanent injunction and a £62,000 costs order

The case ended with a permanent order in our client's favour. On 19 October 2023 Mr Justice Nicklin continued the injunction until trial and, in a second published order, kept the anonymity and reporting restrictions in force. The blackmailers were required to respond formally to the claim. They never did.

We then asked for judgment in default, which is what a court can give when the other side fails to answer a claim. Mrs Justice Steyn gave it on 20 February 2024, deciding the application on paper without a hearing. Her final order bars the blackmailers, with no end date, from using the private material or giving it to anyone. It continues our client's anonymity and orders them to pay his costs, which she assessed at £62,000.

Our client chose to drop his claim for damages. The final order gave him a permanent bar on publication and lasting protection for his name. Each of the court documents in BBG and our other privacy cases can be read in full.

Facing something similar?Get a straight answer here

Advice if you are being blackmailed with intimate material

Please do not pay, and avoid arguing or pleading with them. This is one of the few problems where the usual instinct to sort it out yourself tends to make things worse. Payment tells a blackmailer that you will pay again.

Keep every message, user name and phone number. Those details are what allow a court to make an order against people whose real names you do not know.

Take legal advice before you go to the police, or at the same time. Reporting has its place, and it also puts your private information on their records under your name, so it is worth deciding with a lawyer how and when to do it. In our client's case the police were involved and the injunction still had to come from the civil court.

If the blackmailers have named the people they will send the material to, tell us. A judge wants to know how close the threat is, and a specific threat helps to show the urgency.

Our blackmail and sextortion solicitors guide explains the first steps in more detail, and our record of blackmail injunction cases shows how other clients' cases went. For the wider picture, see the privacy injunctions we have obtained and how to get one.

Lawyers' thoughts about the case

Clients in this position nearly always ask the same question: is there any point applying for a privacy injunction if the person blackmailing me is outside the UK? In most cases there certainly is.

The judge dealt with the point directly. The possibility that an injunction may prove hard to enforce is no reason to refuse it. And nobody could say at that stage that it would be.

Our own experience bears that out. We have acted in cases where the perpetrators were in the United States, in Israel and in a number of African countries. In one case we pursued the matter all the way through a local court in Africa, which found in our client's favour. In other cases we have had UK injunctions domesticated, that is recognised by the local courts, in countries such as Belarus and the United States. All of it was done quickly, efficiently and discreetly.

When blackmailers receive notice of a privacy injunction from us, they tend to look us up, to find out who we are and the kind of work we do. In every case we have handled so far there has been no comeback on us or on the client. They stopped. There could be many reasons, including the fear that we will enforce the injunction in their local court and bring in the local police. In many countries blackmail and extortion are very serious crimes, and we have involved local police before, which took the extortionists quite by surprise.

Blackmailers are in the business of extorting money, and they look for easy targets. In our experience, as soon as they believe they could be caught, or land in any trouble with the law, they stop and move on. It is hardly ever in their interest to keep pursuing a victim once a court order exists, because doing so puts them at needless risk.

The order also reaches further than the blackmailers. Anyone who knows about it and helps to break it can be in contempt of court. For a client whose fear is exposure within one community, that matters a great deal. The people who run a community page, a newspaper or a website in this country are well within the court's reach, and they take an injunction seriously.

Finishing the case mattered too. An emergency injunction is temporary by nature. By carrying the claim through to judgment we turned a holding order into a permanent one, with a costs order that follows the blackmailers if they are ever identified. Whether money can be collected from people like these is a separate question, and the first judge said as much.

The last thought is about the client. He was open about who he is, and they still found a way to threaten him, through a recording he never agreed to. Blackmail works on what a person holds private, and everyone holds something private.

Facing something similar?Get a straight answer here

Frequently asked questions

Can a court stop a blackmailer whose name I do not know?

Yes. The court can make an order against "persons unknown" where they can be identified by what they have done. In BBG v Persons Unknown the judge identified them through the accounts and numbers the threats came from.

Is it worth paying a blackmailer who has a video of me?

We advise against it. Payment rarely ends the demands and tends to invite more. Our client did not solve the problem by ignoring the blackmailers either. What ended it was a court order.

Will the blackmailers find out before the court makes the order?

They need not. The court can hear the application without them being told where a warning might lead them to publish first. Here the judge accepted that a warning could prompt them to publish.

Will my community or the press learn my name from the court case?

The court can keep you anonymous. In this case the first hearing was in private, our client is known only as BBG, and the court banned publication of anything likely to identify him. The final order keeps those protections.

What if the blackmailers are in another country?

A privacy injunction is still worth having in most cases. The court can act where the harm would be felt here, and the judge gave permission for service abroad and by WhatsApp. The order also binds anyone in this country who knows of it and might otherwise help to spread the material. In our experience blackmailers abroad stop once an order reaches them. We have also had UK injunctions recognised by the local courts in countries such as Belarus and the United States.

Do the police need to finish before I go to court?

No. The two can go on at once. Our client had met the police and understood that arrests were unlikely to come quickly, and the court treated his application as urgent.

Can the court order the blackmailers to pay my legal costs?

It can. In BBG the final order requires them to pay £62,000. Collecting from people who conceal who they are is harder, and we would discuss that with you before any application.

Facing something similar?Get a straight answer here

Every situation is a little different, and yours will have its own details. If you want to know where you stand, talk to us in confidence.

Tags: Signature cases | Blackmail injunction cases | Privacy cases
A flat-out, unconditional, no-questions-asked money-back guarantee consultation. Free call 0800 612 7211

Questions about the guarantee? Read the Q&A

More on Blackmail injunctions

Blackmail injunction cases

Privacy cases

Most read