Skip to main content

Internet Law Specialist Lawyers FREE CALL 0800 612 7211

Blackmailed over an affair: the privacy injunction in GJE v SLE

Threatened with exposure of an affair unless you pay: the privacy injunction we obtained in GJE v SLE

Case led by Paul Greenberg, Solicitor specialising in internet law.

This case study is part of our privacy injunctions section.

If someone says they will tell your husband or wife about an affair unless you pay them, we can help you make it go away, and keep you anonymous in the court record while we do it. There is often a temptation to give in to the demand, and there is always the odd chance that a payment makes the whole thing disappear. The chances of that are low, and the risks are substantial. Arguing with them tends to make matters worse too. In 2022 we obtained a privacy injunction of this kind from the High Court for two clients, in the reported case of GJE v SLE, and the privacy injunction was later made permanent.

Threats to tell a wife about an affair unless money was paid: what happened to our clients

Our clients are private people with no public profile. They live in the United States and work for the same company, where one was the other's manager. He was married and she was in a long-term relationship. In 2017 they had a brief affair, which they ended by agreement because he wanted to protect his marriage.

Years later the affair came to light through someone who had been welcomed into the home of one of them. The woman who went on to threaten them had known our client since childhood. In 2020 she travelled to the United States to deal with a family medical crisis, and the two became close. After her relative left hospital, she and the relative lived in our client's home for four weeks before they went back to the UK.

According to our clients' evidence, while she was staying in the house she went into our client's phone and took screenshots. That is how she learned about the affair. The screenshots included a private photograph and a message between the two of them.

The friendship broke down in the second half of 2021, in a disagreement over belongings she had left behind at the house. Between January and May 2022 she contacted our clients online again and again. The judgment describes those messages as angry, abusive and threatening demands for money, which she called compensation for her belongings. If she was not satisfied, she threatened to reveal the affair, including to our client's wife.

Our clients' evidence was that they asked her clearly to stop and that the demands carried on.

Facing something similar?Get a straight answer here

Can you get an emergency privacy injunction out of hours? How we obtained one on a Thursday evening

Yes, you can. We applied to the High Court without telling her first, and on Thursday 26 May 2022 Mr Justice Murray made the order the court later published at five past six in the evening. The order itself gives the court office's hours as ten until four, so the judge acted about two hours after the office had closed for the day. Many people search for this as an emergency injunction. It is an order a judge can make at short notice, before the other person can act on what they have threatened.

The judge accepted there were compelling reasons to keep her in the dark until the order existed. Had she known about the application, she might have acted to defeat its purpose.

The order did four things. It barred her from contacting our clients, their families, their friends and their business associates, and from demanding money. It barred her from passing the private information to anyone else. It required her to tell us within seven days who, if anyone, she had already told, and to hand over copies of the images and videos listed in the order. And it replaced the names with letters, so that our clients became GJE and FJV, and it closed the court file to anyone outside the case.

The judge also allowed us to deliver the order to her by email, text message and WhatsApp, which can put an order in front of someone within minutes.

On the same day we issued a claim for misuse of private information and for harassment under the Protection from Harassment Act 1997.

The later judgment records that she appeared to have ignored every request to stop until the order reached her, and that the threats then stopped.

What the High Court did when the blackmailer stayed away from the hearing

The court went ahead without her and kept the privacy injunction in place. An injunction made without notice is temporary, so the judge fixes a second hearing where the other person can answer. Ours was on 16 June 2022, before Mrs Justice Collins Rice. The woman had the papers, knew the date and had recently said she intended to come. She did not attend and sent no lawyer.

The judge was satisfied that we had given her all the papers and kept her informed. She sent a last-minute, informal explanation, but no evidence, and she did not ask for a later date. The judge also noted that she had not fully complied with the first order, and had not given the formal promises that could have reassured our clients and ended the case.

Because the hearing went ahead in her absence, the judge put her reasons in writing and had them sent to the woman, so that she could take legal advice or ask the court to look again.

"Disclosure once made would be irreversible." Mrs Justice Collins Rice, explaining why money alone could never put things right for our clients.

The hearing itself took place in open court. That was possible because the judge read the private details on paper and nobody spoke them aloud. A court can sit in public and still protect the very thing the case is about.

Facing something similar?Get a straight answer here

Why the court protected a private affair from being exposed for money

The court protected the affair because a person's intimate relationships are private, and our clients were entitled to be free of threats made to extract money. The judge found they were likely to show at trial that they could reasonably expect the affair to stay private. She accepted they were likely to prove that exposure would seriously affect their wellbeing, damage their family lives and put their jobs at risk.

The woman, the judge said, had no discernible right of her own to set against that.

The law the judge applied is section 12 of the Human Rights Act 1998. It tells a court to stop someone speaking before trial only where the person asking is likely to win. The judge had our clients' evidence alone at that stage, because the woman had filed none, and she stressed that her view was provisional. On that evidence she was satisfied the test was met.

One part of the case was less certain. An earlier decision suggests that harassment law in this country only covers harassment a person experiences while they are here, and our clients had been abroad the whole time. The judge left that question open, because the privacy claim was strong enough to support the order without it.

Facing something similar?Get a straight answer here

Advice if someone is threatening to reveal an affair unless you pay

Paying rarely ends it. A person who is paid once tends to come back for more. Arguing with them, or threatening them in return, can push them into acting.

Keep everything they send, with the dates, and take screenshots in case messages are deleted later. Then get advice before you reply again.

In many cases the threats stop once we write to the person. Our letter explains what a court can do to a person who carries on, and it is the quickest and least costly route. Where the person has already ignored requests to stop, or could act at any moment, we can ask a judge for an urgent injunction, as we did here.

Living abroad need not stand in your way. Our clients were thousands of miles away, and the woman behind the threats lived in the UK, which is where the court's order could reach her.

Our guide to the privacy injunctions we have obtained and how to get one explains the process, and there is a separate guide to how an emergency injunction works. If the threats come from strangers online or involve intimate images, our guide for people facing blackmail and sextortion covers that situation. Our other privacy cases on the court record are listed with links to each judgment and order.

Lawyers' thoughts about the case

Three things stay with me from this case, and one more about how we work.

That one first. We were able to go to a judge the same evening because we are an agile and flexible team, and I am grateful for the freedom that gives me. It meant I could act the moment our clients needed me to. I was also glad to have our technical and investigations people under the same roof. They were a great help on this case, and having them in-house saved time when time mattered most.

The first is where the threat came from. People tend to picture a blackmailer as a stranger on the internet. Here it was a guest in the house. Private information can leak just as easily through someone who was trusted with a spare room and was near an unlocked phone. If your phone holds something that could hurt you, the people close to you are nearer to it than any hacker.

The second is that blackmail seldom calls itself blackmail. In this case the demands were described as compensation for belongings. A grievance can be real and the method still unlawful. Once a demand for money arrives with a threat to expose something private, a court is likely to look at what is happening and not at the label.

The third is that I brought two claims side by side, privacy and harassment, and it mattered. The harassment claim met a difficulty because our clients lived abroad. The privacy claim carried the order. For a client overseas, building the case on more than one footing from the first day helps the order survive the second hearing.

A last word on the warning printed on the front of an injunction. The judge said of it: "This is not a formality." A person who breaks an injunction can be arrested, fined or sent to prison. In our experience that warning tends to change behaviour where polite requests have failed.

Frequently asked questions

Can I get a privacy injunction to stop someone exposing an affair to my family?

In many cases, yes. A judge weighs your privacy against the other person's freedom to speak. Where the other person is using the information to demand money, they have very little to put on their side of the scales. In GJE v SLE the High Court found our clients were likely to win on that question and made the order.

What if the person threatening me says I owe them money?

A real complaint about money is no licence to threaten you with exposure. Here the woman presented her demands as compensation for belongings. The court still protected our clients from her threats to reveal the affair. A debt is for a claim in the ordinary way, not for threats.

Can I get a privacy injunction in England if I live abroad?

You may be able to, particularly where the person threatening you lives here. Our clients lived and worked in America, while the woman making the threats lived in this country. The privacy claim supported the injunction. Whether a harassment claim also works for someone abroad is less settled, which is one reason we look at every available claim at the start.

Will my name appear in the court record?

The court can replace your name with letters and restrict who sees the file. It did both here, at the first hearing and again at the second. The published judgment calls our clients GJE and FJV, and the first hearing took place in private.

What does the court do if the blackmailer ignores the hearing?

The court can go ahead without them once it is satisfied they knew about the hearing. It did so here. The judge checked that the woman had the papers and knew the date, found no good reason to delay, and continued the injunction. It was later made permanent.

What happens if someone breaks a privacy injunction?

A person who disobeys an injunction is in contempt of court. The order carries a warning that they may go to prison, be fined or lose assets. Anyone who knows about the order and helps to break it faces the same risk.

How quickly can a judge make a privacy injunction?

A judge can make one at short notice where the threat is pressing, and without the other person being told first. We will move as quickly as you are able to move, and so will the court. The King's Bench Guide confirms that a High Court judge is available out of hours for urgent applications, and we know how to reach one after the working day and organise everything very quickly, while keeping you informed at each step. In this case the judge made the order in the early evening of 26 May 2022, and the second hearing followed three weeks later.

Facing something similar?Get a straight answer here

Every situation is a little different, and yours will have its own details. If you want to know where you stand, talk to us in confidence.

Tags: Signature cases | Blackmail injunction cases | Privacy cases
A flat-out, unconditional, no-questions-asked money-back guarantee consultation. Free call 0800 612 7211

Questions about the guarantee? Read the Q&A

More on Privacy law

Blackmail injunction cases

Privacy cases

Most read